willow vs. Runlayer: Two Approaches to AI Agent Access
Runlayer routes MCP traffic with 18K+ servers. willow is an AI governance platform—shadow AI detection, unified build & runtime guards, infrastructure-as-code via GitHub, a plugin marketplace, and a single CLI for your IDE. Proven at 5,000+ employee orgs.
Willow Admin Console
AI governance platform for AI agents. Shadow AI detection, unified guards, plugin marketplace, infrastructure-as-code, browser extension, and machine users.
Runlayer Control Plane
MCP gateway with 18,000+ servers. Routes and secures MCP traffic with threat detection and enterprise SSO. Backed by MCP spec co-creator.
The Bottom Line
Runlayer is an MCP gateway with 18K+ servers and MCP-specific security, backed by the MCP spec team. willow is an AI governance platform with shadow AI detection, unified build & runtime guards, infrastructure-as-code via GitHub, and a plugin marketplace—battle-tested at scale.
Best for Willow
Enterprises needing AI governance beyond MCP routing—shadow AI detection, unified guards, infrastructure-as-code, and a plugin marketplace.
Best for Archestra
Teams focused on MCP who want 18K+ servers with specialized MCP security and expert backing.
Key Differentiator
willow detects shadow AI, enforces unified guards, and manages governance as code via GitHub. Runlayer is MCP-focused with the largest server catalog.
Give your agents a Basecamp
Feature Comparison
Who Each Solution Is Best For
Willow is Best For
Organizations needing more than MCP routing—an access control plane with IT workflows. Ideal if you:
Runlayer is Best For:
Teams focused on MCP with massive catalog needs and expert backing. Ideal if you:
Architecture Philosophy
MCP pipe vs. access control plane—this shapes protocol support and how you connect to services.
willow provides an access control layer:
- Shadow AI Detection: Discover unmanaged MCPs, skills, and AI agents
- Unified Guards: Build & runtime policy enforcement, easily extensible
- Browser Extension: Enforce governed AI usage wherever employees work
- API to MCP: Convert any API into governed MCP instantly
Runlayer provides an MCP pipe:
- Shadow AI Detection: Discover unmanaged MCPs, skills, and AI agents
- Unified Guards: Build & runtime policy enforcement, easily extensible
- Browser Extension: Enforce governed AI usage wherever employees work
- API to MCP: Convert any API into governed MCP instantly
Deployment & Customization
Both offer flexible deployment with different customization approaches.
willow offers deep customization:
- Plugin Marketplace: Skills, commands, MCPs, hooks—all in one place
- GitHub/GitLab Sync: 2-way sync for Claude, Codex, Cursor integration
- Single CLI: Install your entire gateway in your favorite IDE
- Infrastructure as Code: Manage governance via GitHub—PRs, reviews, approvals
Runlayer offers streamlined MCP deployment:
- Cloud or Self-Hosted: VPC/on-prem options
- One-Click Installs: Deploy without JSON configuration
- No-Code Building: Remix tools into custom MCPs
- Team Sharing: Easy org-wide MCP sharing
Security & Governance
Different specializations: enterprise IT governance vs. MCP-specific threat detection.
willow delivers enterprise governance:
- Shadow AI Detection: Discover unmanaged tools across your org
- Unified Guards: Build & runtime enforcement, easily extensible
- IT Approval Workflows: CISO sign-off, security checks
- SOC 2 Type II: Full audit trails for compliance
Runlayer delivers MCP-focused security:
- Threat Detection: Custom MCP attack vector detectors
- Dynamic Scans: Vulnerability scanning before approval
- EKM/BYOK: Enterprise key management support
- SOC 2 Type II: Enterprise-grade certification
Connectors & Integrations
Catalog size vs. ability to connect to your own services.
willow provides curated connectors + custom:
- Curated MCPs: Hundreds with fine-grained customization
- API to MCP: Convert any REST API to governed MCP
- Direct Connections: Connect without MCP layer when needed
- Version Control: Track versions with rollback
Runlayer provides massive catalog:
- 18,000+ MCPs: Largest catalog available
- Private Registry: Add self-hosted MCPs
- No-Code Remixing: Adapt tools without code
- One-Click Access: Instant server connection
FAQS
Everything you need to know about Willow compared to Archestra
Everything you need to get your Basecamp running.
Your agents are already in the wild.
Give them a Basecamp. Go from AI chaos to AI work, in minutes.
